What Makes a Good Writer? (originally written by Zadie Smith)

Illustration by Garrincha

But if the real duty of writers is to themselves, how can they ever fail? Are we advocating a new “nice” criticism, where all writers get off the hook just because they tried hard, were in good faith? No. What I am imagining is, I hope, a far more thorough reader. My reader holds writers to the same account as the rest…